Fixed-indexed annuities (FIAs) are a popular retirement planning tool because they offer the potential for growth linked to market indices while protecting your principal from market downturns. However, the choice of index within your FIA can significantly impact your returns. Volatility-controlled index options are designed to stabilize returns, but they may not be the best choice for maximizing growth. In this post, we'll explore why low-volatility indices can limit growth and why a higher volatility index like the S&P 500 might be a better option.
Understanding Volatility-Controlled Index Options
Volatility-controlled indices are designed to manage risk by keeping the volatility of returns within a specified range. This is achieved by adjusting the index's exposure to its underlying assets based on market conditions:
Low Volatility = Stable Value: By keeping volatility low, these indices aim to provide stable, predictable returns. However, this stability often comes at the expense of growth potential.
Mechanism: When market volatility increases, these indices reduce their exposure to equities and increase allocations to less volatile assets, like bonds or cash equivalents. Conversely, in stable markets, they may increase exposure to equities.
The Drawbacks of Volatility-Controlled Indices
While stability sounds appealing, especially for risk-averse investors, there are significant downsides to using volatility-controlled indices in your FIA:
Limited Growth Potential: The primary drawback of low-volatility indices is their limited growth potential. In stable or rising markets, these indices may not capture the full extent of market gains.
Opportunity Cost: By focusing on stability, you might miss out on higher returns available through more volatile indices. This opportunity cost can be significant over the long term, particularly in a retirement account where compound growth is crucial.
Reduced Compounding Effect: The power of compound interest relies on strong, consistent returns. Low-volatility indices, with their stable but modest returns, do not harness this effect as effectively as higher-volatility indices.
Why High-Volatility Indices Like the S&P 500 Make More Sense
In the context of a fixed-indexed annuity, where your principal is protected from market losses, opting for a higher-volatility index can make more sense:
Higher Growth Potential: High-volatility indices like the S&P 500 have historically offered higher returns over the long term compared to low-volatility options. By capturing more significant market gains, these indices can help your annuity grow more robustly.
Principal Protection: The primary advantage of an FIA is that it shields your principal from market downturns. This means you can afford to choose a more volatile index without worrying about losing your initial investment.
Better Compounding: With the potential for higher returns, high-volatility indices can harness the power of compound interest more effectively, leading to greater growth in your retirement savings over time.
Example Scenario
Consider the following comparison between a low-volatility index and a high-volatility index within an FIA:
Low-Volatility Index: With a 5% volatility control, the index might offer stable returns of around 3-4% per year in an average market.
High-Volatility Index (e.g., S&P 500): With typical market volatility around 16%, the S&P 500 might provide average annual returns of 7-10%, capturing more significant gains during market upswings.
While the low-volatility index provides stability, the high-volatility index offers substantially higher growth potential, especially over a longer investment horizon.
The Role of a Knowledgeable Agent
Selecting the right index for your FIA requires understanding the trade-offs between stability and growth potential. A knowledgeable financial advisor can:
Provide Expertise: Explain the implications of different index choices and how they align with your retirement goals.
Tailored Recommendations: Recommend indices that suit your risk tolerance and financial objectives, ensuring you make the most of your FIA.
Conclusion
While volatility-controlled index options in fixed-indexed annuities offer stability, they often come at the cost of limited growth potential. Given the principal protection feature of FIAs, opting for a high-volatility index like the S&P 500 can make more sense. These indices offer higher growth potential without increasing your risk, thanks to the annuity's protective features. To maximize your retirement savings, consider working with a knowledgeable advisor who can guide you in selecting the most suitable index options for your financial goals.
By choosing indices that align with your growth objectives, you can harness the full potential of your fixed-indexed annuity, ensuring a more prosperous and secure retirement.
If you have an annuity that has not been growing, watch my link below to find out what you can do to get back on track: